top of page

Hungarian Pilots Protest: Why Do Some Seek Medical Certification Abroad?

Writer: Pakuts Tamás
Pakuts Tamás
2 days ago
10 min read

Hungarian pilots are demonstrating on 14 September 2026 over the functioning of the aviation authority and aeromedical certification system. This could be dismissed as a dispute involving a few dissatisfied pilots, except that two national aviation associations say they have observed problems for almost six years and have been trying to resolve them throughout that period.


If six years of professional dialogue have not been enough, what exactly is failing in Hungarian aviation?

On Monday morning, Hungarian pilots are marching in protest and plan to submit a twelve-point petition. Their complaints include what they regard as unjustified or disproportionate aeromedical decisions, lengthy procedures, psychological assessments, additional health checks and regulatory practices that can ground individuals for months when their livelihood depends on holding a valid medical certificate. The demonstrators demand a comprehensive review of Hungarian practice, comparison with other European systems and reconsideration of the contested decision-making mechanisms. The Ministry of Transport and Investment told the press it was aware of the demonstration, had already met representatives of the protesters and would receive and examine the petition.


This alone would not make the story exceptional. People in conflict with authorities usually feel they have been treated unfairly, and the stakes in aviation are especially high: being declared medically unfit can mean not merely the absence of a stamp but the abrupt interruption of a career spanning decades. That is why the protesters' claims should not automatically be accepted as fact. One much more uncomfortable circumstance, however, prevents the issue from being dismissed as individual grievances of a few pilots.


Even Those Not Protesting Say Something Is Wrong


The Hungarian Aviation and Air Sports Association (MRLSZ) issued a statement on 10 September making clear it was neither organising nor participating in the demonstration. It continued to favour professional dialogue, consultation and negotiated solutions. That would hardly be surprising from a national professional association. The next part of its statement, however, was more interesting: MRLSZ itself acknowledged problems in the operation of the aeromedical system and said it had been working continuously for almost six years to make it more predictable and better suited to the aviation community. It added that long-standing problems urgently required solutions.


Then the Hungarian Gliding Association (MVSZ) published a statement conveying essentially the same message. It too distanced itself from the protest and supported a negotiated settlement, but also referred to problems existing for almost six years which it had been trying to resolve with the organisations and authorities concerned. The two statements were strikingly similar even in their wording.


How can two national aviation associations have identified and reported problems with the same system, held discussions and searched for solutions for almost six years, only to say in autumn 2026 that the problems remain and require urgent resolution?


Six years is an exceptionally long time in aviation. During that period airlines appear and disappear, fleets are replaced, new aircraft types enter service, regulations change and thousands of pilots gain new qualifications. If a professional problem cannot be solved at the negotiating table in so much time, it is reasonable to ask whether this is really a problem of dialogue or something deeper within the organisation and regulator.



An Aeromedical Certificate Is Not a Family Doctor's Note


At this point some caution is needed, because the discussion could easily head in the wrong direction. Aeromedical systems do not exist to annoy pilots. The physical and mental fitness of an airline pilot is not purely private. The immediate ability of someone flying a Boeing, an Airbus or even a smaller commercial aircraft can directly affect dozens or hundreds of lives.


European requirements are particularly strict. Pilots exercising commercial pilot, MPL or ATPL privileges need a valid Class 1 medical certificate, and EASA regulates medical fitness in considerable detail. After the 2015 Germanwings Flight 9525 tragedy, Europe further tightened the oversight of pilots' mental health, psychological assessments, alcohol and drug screening, aeromedical examiners and the support systems available to pilots.


The problem is not thorough medical examination in Hungary or a referral for additional tests. When clinically justified, such tests are necessary. Nor is examining psychiatric or psychological risks the problem. They must be addressed.


The question is which rules apply, how decisions are justified professionally, how consistently the system operates, what deadlines exist and how effective appeals are. A safety-critical system may be strict; indeed, it must be. It should not be unpredictable, inconsistent or dependent on a doctor's mood.


What Does Two Months on the Ground Mean? That Depends on How You Earn Your Living.


A suspended medical certificate may look from the outside like an administrative procedure. A pilot receives a letter, attends additional tests, submits documents and waits. But every day has concrete consequences for a professional pilot: without the appropriate medical certificate there is no flying, and without flying there may be no income from work.


Before the demonstration, Repuloiskola.hu interviewed experienced pilot, instructor and former Malév captain László Tóth. He says a medical certificate that had already been issued was subsequently suspended and that he was asked to undergo an exercise ECG and cardiac CT. Privately arranged testing cost him over HUF 200,000. He says he regained certification after satisfactory results, but could not fly for over two months and had to take unpaid leave. According to his account, an appeal against a later restriction remained unresolved after more than ninety days.


This is one person's story. One case cannot condemn an entire regulatory system, but it can explain why the speed and quality of decisions are critical. If a pilot ultimately proves fit but cannot work for months before the decision, it is not enough to ask whether the final medical conclusion was correct. We must also ask whether the entire process was justified, the restrictions proportionate, the decision could have been faster and why the pilot carried all the lost-time and lost-income risk.


This is especially important in an industry facing pilot shortages, training-capacity constraints and extremely high training costs worldwide. An experienced captain or instructor cannot be replaced overnight.



Hungarian Pilots Can Fly — Just Not Necessarily with Hungarian Medical Certification


One particularly interesting aspect of the case is that Hungarian pilots do not necessarily have to arrange every aeromedical matter in Hungary. EASA makes it clear that a valid medical certificate issued by an authorised examiner in another EASA member state must be recognised by the other member states without additional validation.


This matters because it would be easy to dismiss pilots seeking examinations abroad as simply searching for a doctor who will pass them. The European system is not intended to operate as twenty-seven separate medical worlds with different standards of safety, but on common minimum requirements, mutual recognition and the exchange of safety information.


The demonstration organiser told Index that, in his view, growing numbers of Hungarian pilots were arranging their affairs abroad, with five pilots turning to the Romanian system in the preceding month alone. László Tóth said he had transferred his pilot licence to Bulgaria, while others, in his experience, were turning to Austria, Czechia, Slovenia, Romania, Germany or Sweden. These remain the claims of those concerned. We did not find publicly available national statistics showing how many Hungarian pilots chose another EASA member state, or why.

That could be one of the most revealing datasets. If only a few people do this each year, there may be little story. But if a sustained trend exists in which Hungarian pilots accept extra time, costs and administration to come under another country's authority, a well-functioning regulator ought to know why.

Losing a customer is not merely a signal in a hotel. It is a signal for a regulatory authority too.


Pilots Are Not the Only Ones Who Encounter This


I have a personal experience from another internationally regulated transport industry. For the past decade I have arranged my seafarer medical examinations in Vienna and Bratislava, because I found the procedures simpler, smoother and substantially cheaper in both cities, while the medical examinations themselves were at least as thorough as those I had previously experienced in Hungary.


The difference was not that doctors abroad were less interested in my health. Quite the opposite. In Vienna and Bratislava they accepted my previous test results, laboratory reports and medical history downloaded from Hungary's EESZT system. They used those records to decide which additional examinations were genuinely necessary. They did not impose unnecessary costs and trusted their medical colleagues' assessments, though on occasion they did consult by telephone.


In Hungary, by contrast, my experience was that a doctor would accept the same information and tests only if they were repeated as new, privately paid investigations — moreover, through a service provider specifically selected by that doctor.


Seafarer and pilot medical certifications are governed by different rules and are not directly comparable. But the pattern is all too familiar: the same safety goal may be achieved abroad not through fewer checks, but through less pointless administration, better use of previous records and more predictable procedures.


Why did a result already available in a Hungarian medical database have to be repeated privately, at a particular location, in Hungary, when the same medical history was accepted in two other European countries? No comment.


Safety Is Not the Same as Maximising Unnecessary Restrictions and Bans


The debate around pilots' mental health may be the most sensitive part of the entire case, precisely because flight safety and the protection of private medical information must both be respected. EASA's current framework expressly requires mental-health assessment, and initial Class 1 certification includes a comprehensive evaluation. Psychiatric or clinical psychological opinions are required in defined circumstances, while EU regulations specify the qualifications of the professionals who must carry out those assessments.


Modern flight-safety thinking, however, no longer assumes that every problem is best resolved by the harshest possible penalty or immediately removing a pilot. EASA-required pilot support programmes follow the opposite logic: pilots should be willing to seek help early, have confidential access to support, receive treatment and, where safe, return to flying. EASA guidance also expressly addresses fear of losing a licence and ways to mitigate the associated financial consequences.


This is not an 'allow sick pilots to fly' philosophy. Quite the contrary. If pilots fear that honestly disclosing a minor physical or mental-health problem could deprive them of their livelihood for an unpredictable period, a dangerous incentive appears: say nothing.


An overly permissive aeromedical system is dangerous. Paradoxically, a system that makes people afraid to ask for help in time can also create a safety risk.


Hungary's Aviation Authority Is Not Some Distant Institution in Brussels


The Hungarian Civil Aviation Licensing Department performs national aeromedical regulatory duties. Its official responsibilities also include pilot licensing and examinations, supervision of training organisations, certification of flight simulation equipment and other aviation medical regulatory functions.


Here we arrive at issues much more interesting than the demonstration itself. How many Class 1 medical certificates have been suspended in Hungary over the past six years? How many pilots were found unfit? How often were these decisions later changed? How long did contested cases take on average? How many additional cardiology, psychology or psychiatric examinations were ordered? How many decisions were appealed? In how many cases did review ultimately find in favour of the pilot?


Another figure would be especially revealing: how many Hungarian pilots transferred their professional licence or aeromedical administration to another EASA member state in recent years?


Those data would tell us far more about the system than whether fifty, one hundred or two hundred people attend Monday's demonstration.


While preparing the article, Szalloda.blog contacted the Hungarian aviation authority, the Ministry of Transport and Investment, the Hungarian Aviation and Air Sports Association and the Hungarian Gliding Association. We asked, among other things, what problems had been discussed for almost six years, what changes professional bodies proposed, which had been implemented, whether the authority had figures on medical certificates suspended and later amended, and whether it had observed Hungarian pilots moving abroad. We will update the article if responses arrive.



After Six Years of Talks, 'We Are Talking' Is No Longer an Answer


The two professional associations' statements are far stronger than they first appear. Neither attacks officials or identifies anyone to blame. Neither supports the demonstration; both expressly distance themselves from it. That makes their shared acknowledgment especially serious: problems have existed for almost six years, they have been working on solutions throughout that period, and those problems still require prompt resolution.


That raises a simple management question. If a critical process in a company remained faulty for six years despite continuous discussions, eventually the question would cease being when to schedule the next meeting. Instead, people would ask why six years of meetings had produced no result.


We should not set a lower standard for a public authority. Aviation is known for collecting data on significant incidents, investigating causes, analysing trends and assigning corrective action. If a technical system reported the same fault for six years, continued constructive dialogue would hardly be considered an acceptable response. The regulatory system must meet reliability standards no lower than those of the aircraft whose pilot it supervises.


The Dispute Is Not About Whether Everyone Deserves a Medical Certificate


Anyone whose health prevents safe flying must not fly. If specialist examinations, psychological assessment, temporary restrictions or loss of medical certification are necessary, flight safety takes precedence. There is no compromise on that.


But the same logic works in the other direction. If someone is fit, the system must determine that on sound professional grounds, consistently and within a reasonable time. Additional tests require clear clinical justification. Restrictions must be explained. Contested decisions require effective and timely review. If an entire professional community reports the same issues for years, eventually the regulator's own performance must also be examined.


Monday's demonstration is therefore not about pilots wishing to decide for themselves whether they are fit to fly. We should not let the argument be reduced to that.


The more uncomfortable question is this: if Europe works under common flight-safety rules, how is it possible that some Hungarian pilots believe the same European system will serve them better, faster or more predictably in Romania, Bulgaria, Austria or Czechia?


If this is merely the impression of a few individuals, data will reveal it. And if not, the data will reveal that too.


What happened over these six years? Who reported what, what was promised, what changed and what did not? If six years of professional consultation are followed by street demonstrations, did the consultation process fail — or the regulatory system being discussed?




Sources and Related Documents

Hungarian Aviation and Air Sports Association, statement, 10 September 2026.

Hungarian Gliding Association, statement, 10 September 2026.

Transport Authority — Civil Aviation Licensing Department, official description of functions and organisation.

Index — Report on the 14 September demonstration and organisers' demands, 11 September 2026.

Repuloiskola.hu — Interview with pilot László Tóth, 12 September 2026.

EASA — Part-MED, European aeromedical certification rules and mutual recognition of medical certificates issued in other EASA member states.

EASA — Mental health, aeromedical and pilot-support measures introduced after Germanwings Flight 9525.


The legal, regulatory, industry and international information in this article reflects the position as of 13 September 2026. AI tools, including ChatGPT and Claude, assisted in collecting, comparing and organising the material. Final editing, interpretation and conclusions reflect the editorial position of Szalloda.blog. AI-based applications also assisted with some illustrations and infographic elements.

This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.

Comments


bottom of page