top of page

Is Airbnb to Blame for the Housing Crisis — or Simply the Easiest Target?

Writer: Pakuts Tamás
Pakuts Tamás
2 days ago
11 min read

What Is Brussels Planning for — or Against — Short-Term Rentals?


Our earlier article examined how Hungary might bring order to tourist apartment rentals without treating a ban on Airbnb as the only answer. The European Union may go much further: where affordable housing is under threat, authorities could limit not only the conditions under which homes are rented short term, but also their number. Yet identifying the easiest market participant to blame does not create more housing.


For a long time, debate over Airbnb regulation appeared primarily to concern tourism and consumer protection. Is a property registered? Does it meet compulsory safety and hygiene standards? Does the guest receive what the listing promised? Does anyone inspect the accommodation, or are carefully lit photographs, four decorative cushions and an enthusiastic host profile enough?


In 'Do Not Ban Airbnb — Put the Market in Order: Fifteen Proposals for a New Hungarian Regulatory Framework for Tourist Rentals', we began with the fact that Airbnb is a sales platform, not an accommodation category. The activity behind the listing, rather than the platform's name, is what should be regulated.


We distinguished occasional home-sharing, someone renting out a room in their own home, an investor letting a separate tourist apartment and a professional operator managing a portfolio. As we wrote: 'Anyone who tries to regulate these four models under the single word Airbnb has already lost the plot.'


The emerging EU framework extends that debate. It asks not only under what conditions tourist apartments may operate, but whether housing pressure can justify limiting their number, annual operating days or new permits.



First the EU Asked for Data. Now It Is Considering Limits.


Two separate processes matter in European regulation of Airbnb and similar platforms. One is already in force and focuses on data collection, registration and oversight. The other is still being developed and could define when member states, regions or municipalities may impose quantitative limits on short-term rentals.


What Has Already Changed in 2026?


An EU regulation adopted in 2024 and applicable from 20 May 2026 establishes a more consistent data-collection and sharing system for short-term accommodation. Authorities should no longer need to rely on estimates, occasional searches of platforms and incompatible local registers to determine how many homes are used for tourism.


The main elements of the already applicable EU framework are:

  • Single registration number: where a member state or municipality maintains a registration system, each rental unit may have a unique identifier.

  • Mandatory display of registration numbers: platform listings must show the accommodation identifier, making unlawfully operated properties easier to detect.

  • Platform verification obligations: Airbnb, Booking.com and other relevant intermediaries must allow basic registration information to be submitted and checked. This does not mean on-site quality inspections of every home, but platforms can no longer consider themselves entirely neutral noticeboards.

  • Regular data reporting: platforms must share information including the number of rented nights, guest numbers and details needed to identify accommodation and providers with relevant authorities.

  • A central digital entry point: member states must establish systems through which platforms can submit data consistently.

  • Easier removal of unlawful listings: missing, invalid or withdrawn registration numbers allow authorities to identify advertisements more precisely and seek their removal.

The regulation does not create one European Airbnb licence, a uniform cap on rental nights or a general ban. The EU first wants member states and municipalities to base decisions on reliable data.



What Might the Next EU Framework Introduce?


A draft seen by Reuters would go further. The European Commission is expected to propose a common legal framework more clearly defining when restrictions on short-term apartment rentals may be justified to protect affordable housing.

Based on the ideas currently known and models already operating in European cities, possible changes include:


  • Defining housing pressure: generic claims that there are too many Airbnb listings or that housing is expensive would be insufficient. Relevant indicators could include home prices relative to local income, rent trends, scarce supply, population change and concentration of tourist apartments.

  • Caps on the number of rentals: highly affected neighbourhoods could impose maximum numbers of short-term units or newly issued permits.

  • Annual caps on rented nights: authorities could set a maximum number of short-term rental days per year, possibly differentiating primary residences from investment properties run commercially year-round.

  • Geographically differentiated rules: a crowded historic city centre should not face identical restrictions to a rural area short of tourists. Limits might vary even between neighbourhoods or smaller geographic zones.

  • Distinguishing private from commercial activity: letting one's own home for a few weeks could receive different treatment from operating an apartment portfolio.

  • Restrictions on new market entry: existing operators might continue while no new permits are granted. This risks increasing the value of existing authorisations and reducing competition.

  • Permits and periodic reassessment: registration need not confer an unlimited right to operate. Renewal could depend on local housing conditions, tax and safety compliance and condominium rules.

  • Stronger platform responsibility: platforms may need not only to transmit data but technically prevent bookings with invalid permits, in forbidden areas or above night limits.

  • Faster delisting: authorities could seek suspension or removal of unlawful advertisements through more consistent procedures.

  • Mandatory impact review: bans and quotas might have to be periodically reassessed against actual new long-term housing, rents and tourism or economic losses.

It is essential to emphasise that some of these are potential elements of a future EU framework, not adopted rules. The text may change substantially when proposed and during negotiations in the European Parliament and Council.



Can National and Municipal Regulation Continue?


Yes. The EU is unlikely to dictate from Brussels how many days an apartment may be rented in Budapest, Barcelona or a Balaton town. Concrete restrictions may remain decisions for member states, regions and local authorities. Current EU law already allows this. Regulation (EU) 2024/1028 expressly recognises that member states may maintain or introduce:


  • Health and safety requirements;

  • Mandatory quality minimums;

  • Registration or permit systems;

  • Land-use and building regulations;

  • Housing and tenancy rules;

  • Quantitative restrictions.


But national and local rules cannot be arbitrary. They must pursue a legitimate public-interest objective and be non-discriminatory, necessary and proportionate. The Court of Justice of the EU has recognised that addressing shortages of long-term rental housing can justify limits on short-term accommodation. However, each measure must still be supported by evidence of the problem and assessed against less restrictive, equally effective alternatives.


The new EU framework may therefore constrain rather than remove national and municipal discretion. It could specify evidence required to establish housing pressure, acceptable restriction types, proportionality justifications and periodic outcome reviews.

That is a crucial difference. The EU may not decide which places should have fewer Airbnb listings. It may require those seeking limits to prove why they are needed.



Protecting Guests and Protecting Housing Are Different Tasks


The two problems should be separated because they demand different evidence and responses.


If a rental is unsafe, advertises misleadingly, violates hygiene standards, fails to issue invoices or operates illegally, that is a regulatory and consumer-protection matter. It makes no difference whether the property is listed on an international platform, its own website or a phone number on a gate: it must be inspected and violations sanctioned.


The housing crisis is different. Authorities must establish whether short-term renting materially reduces the supply of local homes, raises rents or property prices, displaces residents or undermines the functioning of a neighbourhood.


The issues can overlap but are not interchangeable. A fully compliant Airbnb can still remove an apartment from the long-term market. Closing an illegally operated apartment does not resolve a citywide housing crisis caused by decades of underbuilding, weak rental housing, speculative investment and incomes disconnected from property prices.


The housing crisis cannot be loaded onto a few rolling suitcases.


There Is a Relationship, but No Simple Formula for Every City


Research by the European Commission's Joint Research Centre examining Paris, Milan and Rome found a statistically significant positive relationship between the share of short-term rentals and advertised property prices in Milan and Rome. This suggests tourist use may contribute to higher prices in certain heavily affected neighbourhoods.


The findings were more complex overall. Short-term renting did not relate to local liveability in the same way everywhere, and residents did not necessarily consider stronger tourism areas less liveable. Correlation also does not always establish direct causation: tourists and investors may already be attracted to neighbourhoods that are desirable, accessible and valuable.


That makes it dangerous to assume politically that whenever homes are expensive, Airbnb must be the culprit. It may be part of the problem, but the magnitude varies by city, district and even street.


Barcelona's historic centre, a tourist neighbourhood in Rome, Budapest's District VII, a Balaton resort and a depopulating Hungarian village cannot sensibly be governed by identical rules. An activity displacing residents in one place may support an otherwise vacant family home, local business or even a whole village's tourism economy elsewhere.



Hungary Has Already Moved Ahead


Budapest has a moratorium from 1 January 2025 through 31 December 2026: no new private or other accommodation may be registered in NTAK. Previously registered operators may continue, so the city has effectively frozen new entry into the short-term rental market.


A major tax increase accompanied the measure. The annual flat-rate tax on rooms in Budapest rose from HUF 38,400 to HUF 150,000, approximately €385, per room.


Terézváros went further. In a local referendum in Budapest's District VI, 54% of voters supported banning short-term accommodation; turnout was 20.52%. The municipality then set the permitted annual operating period for private and other accommodation at zero days, effectively ending the service in the district from 1 January 2026.


The Budapest moratorium and the Terézváros ban are very different. A moratorium does not close existing accommodation. On the contrary, it protects those operators from new competitors. Existing operating rights may acquire commercial value while new owners and entrepreneurs cannot enter the market. The number of Airbnbs does not necessarily fall, but competition certainly weakens.


An outright ban is clearer but much harsher. It does not differentiate occasional rental of one's home, professionally operated portfolios, resident owners and remote investors. Instead of defining acceptable operations, it eliminates the activity. A zero-day limit is simple to enforce. That does not automatically make it good regulation.


Will Those Homes Actually Return to Local Residents?


This is the debate's most important promise, yet one that is rarely demonstrated.


Supporters of restrictions assume that homes previously rented through Airbnb will enter the long-term rental market, increasing supply and reducing rents. The logic is plausible, but the outcome is not automatic.


Owners may choose long-term rental, but could also sell, leave the property vacant, offer medium-term lets, convert it to corporate housing or seek another legal use. Risks, taxation, legal conditions and expected returns on long-term tenancies affect their decisions just as much as restrictions on short-term accommodation.

If we do not measure how many homes actually return to local rental supply, what happens to rents and vacancies, and how neighbourhood businesses are affected, we are making a political gesture rather than housing policy.


Hotels May Win — but the Destination Might Not


At first glance, restricting short-term accommodation clearly benefits hotels. Competing capacity may shrink, demand and occupancy may rise, and higher room rates may become possible.


But hotels and Airbnb properties do not always compete for the same guest. A large family, a digital worker staying several weeks or someone who needs a kitchen may not simply book two or three hotel rooms because their apartment disappears. They may choose another neighbourhood, destination or a shorter visit.


A city may openly decide it wants only higher-spending tourists. But this should not automatically be called sustainability or housing policy. Artificially reducing accommodation choices can create a two-speed city where travel increasingly becomes a privilege of the affluent.

Fair competition for hotels does not mean eliminating other accommodation forms. It means all providers performing comparable activities meet basic safety, tax, reporting and consumer-protection obligations.



Not All Airbnb Rentals Are Alike


A basic flaw in regulation is treating 'Airbnb' as one uniform business model. As our earlier article showed, at least four different activities lie behind the label:

  • Occasional home-sharing while the owner is away;

  • Letting a room in the owner's residence while the host remains there;

  • Operating a separate apartment dedicated to tourism;

  • A professional business managing a portfolio of apartments.


The first two approaches are close to platforms' original sharing-economy promise. The fourth is a commercial accommodation business, typically without a reception desk, shared areas or readily visible staff.


Regulation should recognise these differences. Someone letting their home for twenty nights a year is not the same as an operator managing twenty apartments year-round. Treating them identically is simpler but hard to defend professionally.


When Would Restrictions Make Sense?


The potential value of the EU's new approach is requiring data and demonstrable conditions for decisions. Municipalities should not ban short-term renting simply because it is popular in the current political climate, but because housing pressure has been established and the restriction is proportionate.

At a minimum, the following should be examined:


  • The share of locally available housing represented by entire homes rented short term;

  • How much of that supply operates commercially throughout the year;

  • Changes in long-term rental supply and rents relative to local incomes;

  • How many homes remain persistently vacant;

  • The number of newly built homes and obstacles limiting construction;

  • Whether earlier restrictions actually returned more affordable long-term rentals;

  • Changes in hotel rates, guest nights, lengths of stay and local business revenues.


Restrictions should also undergo periodic review. If they fail to deliver the stated housing objective, they should be changed or removed. A ban introduced once must not become a permanent political monument.



Not Simply Banning or Protecting, but Distinguishing


Regulation of short-term renting is justified. We need transparent registers, real platform data, safety minimums, fair taxation, complaint handling and effective consumer protection. Platforms cannot indefinitely hide behind the idea that they merely provided a digital space for guests and hosts to meet.


Quantitative limits can also be legitimate if a substantial proportion of a neighbourhood's homes is permanently used for tourism, resident displacement is measurable and less restrictive instruments have failed.


But the order matters. First define the problem, then demonstrate its causes, then choose a proportionate response. Not ban Airbnb first and hope it might somehow make housing cheaper.


Airbnb Is Neither Innocent nor a Universal Villain


In some neighbourhoods it has contributed to the conversion of housing into tourism accommodation, rising prices and disruption of everyday life. Elsewhere it has created bed capacity, visitors and local revenues that would not have existed without hotel investment.


The EU will help if its new framework enforces evidence-based, proportionate and locally differentiated decisions instead of a central ban. Budapest must show not just how many Airbnbs exist, but what precise housing problems they cause and whether restrictions imposed so far have actually improved matters.


If in two years there are fewer short-term rentals and more expensive hotel rooms, but not one additional affordable home, we will not have solved the housing crisis. We will simply have found somebody to blame.




Sources and Bibliography

Related Szalloda.blog Articles

EU Legislation and Documents

Research and Professional Background

Press Sources and Hungarian Context


The legal, regulatory, industry and international information used for this article reflects the position as of 5 September 2026. AI tools (ChatGPT and Claude) assisted with collecting, comparing and organising information. Final editing, interpretation and conclusions represent Szalloda.blog's editorial position. AI tools were also used for some illustrations and infographics.

This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.

Comments


bottom of page