Robinson Tours: Was the Charter Insurance Limit Based on Incomplete Declarations?
Negligence or Deception?

The most interesting question in the Robinson Tours case is no longer simply whether its insurance cover was insufficient. It is how that amount of cover came about. According to a further six-page reply sent by Axiom Insurance Company to szalloda.blog, the insured amounts were determined on the basis of turnover declared by Robinson and documents it submitted. From an earlier Axiom response we also know that the insurance documentation explicitly stated that the company offered organised travel packages including charter flights. Bulgarian regulations, however, prescribe a minimum four times the amount of cover ultimately held by Robinson for such packages. Was this negligence, a different interpretation of the law, inaccurate declarations — or something else?
When Robinson Tours' charter departures from Budapest and Debrecen were cancelled in early August, our main questions concerned what happened to the flights, how passengers would return, who would refund them and what insurance the Bulgarian tour operator actually held. Since then, more documents have emerged, and the most interesting issue is increasingly the insurance arrangement itself rather than the mechanics of settling claims. We began examining the background in our article 'What Happened to the Robinson Tours Charter Flights? Two Departures Cancelled from Budapest and Debrecen'. There we already noted an apparent serious inconsistency between the insurance cover disclosed by Robinson and Bulgarian requirements for packages containing charter flights. (Szallodablog.)
AXIOM Responded to Our Questions in Detail
Axiom's reply of 31 August shows three successive insurance policies. The first two digits of each policy number refer to the year of issue, but the insurance term did not follow the calendar year: Robinson's cycle ran from September to the following September. The current policy, number 251370068, for example, was valid from 20 September 2025 to 19 September 2026. The limits under the three successive policies were first BGN 75,000, then BGN 125,000, and finally BGN 125,000 again.
These figures should not, however, be examined in isolation. What matters is how they were determined.
Axiom's original letter in English is available here:
Its Hungarian translation can be read here:
What Turnover Did the Insurer See for Robinson Tours?
Axiom has now confirmed that it set premiums and limits through its own underwriting process, risk assessment and the financial documentation formally submitted by Robinson. It will not disclose the exact turnover, citing commercial and financial confidentiality, but it does confirm that the limits were based on the turnover declared by Robinson Tours for compulsory insurance. The insurer also stresses that, under Bulgarian tourism law, responsibility for fully and accurately declaring the relevant information rests with the party making the declaration. This has now become one of the most important figures in the case.
As a Bulgarian company, Robinson also conducted substantial sales activity in Hungary. We still do not know what turnover Robinson declared or how its Hungarian sales were reflected in those figures. If all relevant turnover was properly included, the applied insurance limit needs to be explained. If some was omitted, we need to understand why.
The Charter Activity Was Not Discovered After the Event
In an earlier official response to szalloda.blog, Axiom said that Robinson explicitly declared in the questionnaire completed when taking out the insurance that its activities included 'organised tourist packages including charter flights'. Yet in the same documentation Robinson requested an insurance limit equal to only a quarter of the minimum applicable to charter packages.
The relevant provision of the Bulgarian Tourism Act states that a tour operator offering packages including charter flights must maintain a separately specified minimum level of compulsory insurance. Robinson's actual cover was only one quarter of that amount. This is why Axiom itself is still examining the issue: it said in an earlier response that it would further assess the legal consequences of the questionnaire's charter declaration in light of the statutory minimum, without prejudging its final legal position before all facts and documents have been clarified.
One detail remains unknown, however: what exactly did 'charter' mean in Robinson's response to its insurer?
It makes a difference whether Robinson chartered the aircraft itself and bore the capacity risk, or bought seats from capacity contracted by another party — such as a charter broker, agent or other tour operator — and incorporated them into its own travel packages.
This is not merely theoretical. Electra Airways previously told szalloda.blog that the flights were part of a contractual chain involving an agent and broker alongside the tour operator. The airline later said it had not received the fee due for operating the charter services. We published Electra's replies in our continuously updated article 'Robinson Tours: How Hungarian Passengers Can Submit Their Claims'. (Szallodablog.)
That raises an important question still unanswered: who was actually Electra Airways' direct contractual charter partner? Did Robinson contract directly with the airline, or was another party involved? Who booked the capacity, who bore its financial risk and who was directly obliged to pay Electra?
The absence of an unequivocal answer from Electra proves nothing by itself. Nevertheless, the agent–broker–Robinson arrangement raises the possibility that Robinson sold travel packages containing charter flights while not necessarily considering itself the party that chartered the aircraft.
That is why access to the full original insurance questionnaire would be important. Did Axiom ask whether Robinson itself chartered aircraft, whether it organised charter flights or whether it sold travel packages that included charter flights?
There is a further complication. The wording of the Bulgarian rule does not simply refer to the tour operator that physically contracts for the aircraft, but to one that offers travel packages including charter flights. Thus, even if Robinson was not the charterer in the traditional sense, whether that would exempt it from the higher insurance minimum would remain a legal question requiring determination.
The Insurer Itself Saw a Higher Risk
The situation is further complicated by Axiom's earlier statement that Robinson's insurance premium was set substantially above the standard reference tariff for its turnover category. The insurer attributed this specifically to the risk assessment performed when the contract was concluded.
The 31 August letter also shows that Axiom says it was unaware of some elements of Robinson's actual market activity. We specifically asked about Montenegro and Albania; the insurer replied that it had not been informed, formally or informally, that Robinson offered or sold travel products relating to those destinations.
What Did the Competent Bulgarian Ministry Know?
The story no longer concerns Robinson and Axiom alone. According to the insurer's reply of 31 August, to the best of its knowledge all three policies were accepted by Bulgaria's Ministry of Tourism and duly recorded in the register.
Robinson provided declarations, Axiom assessed the risk and issued policies, and the insurance contracts entered the Bulgarian regulatory register.
In this connection, a Robinson Tours claimant submitted a freedom-of-information request to Bulgaria's Ministry of Tourism. The ministry's reply, issued as a formal decision, indicated among other things that the Bulgarian authority had not carried out a cross-border check in 2020 concerning Áron Jakócs's position in Hungary, had no information about the Hungarian Robinson-Tours Kft. case at that time or related Hungarian–Bulgarian regulatory communications, and neither collects nor possesses information on services provided in Hungary by Neptun Tours EOOD.
That does not answer the professional questions raised by the present insurance case. Szalloda.blog is therefore still awaiting a detailed position from Bulgaria's Ministry of Tourism on where and how anyone checked that the turnover declared by Robinson, its reported activities and the insurance cover issued were consistent with one another and with the law.
The Coverage Is Already Insufficient
This is not an academic dispute. At the present stage of claims settlement, the insurance fund already appears, to put it mildly, inadequate.
According to Axiom's 31 August reply, 245 claims had been registered by 26 August, concerning at least 588 people. The total amount claimed already exceeded the entire available insurance limit many times over. If the claims ultimately found eligible and covered also exceed the fund, payments will be made proportionately.
The insurer examines each claim individually, verifying among other things the contractual documentation, payment, the reason the service was not delivered and any amounts recovered from other sources.
The insurer had not yet registered any formal insurance claims from service providers, hotels, airlines or other Robinson partners. At least one legal entity had, however, informed Axiom that Robinson owed it unpaid sums; the legal assessment of that notification was still under way.
For affected Hungarian passengers, we compiled claims-settlement guidance and Axiom's earlier answers in our continuously updated article 'Robinson Tours: How Hungarian Passengers Can Submit Their Claims'.
Insurance Had Already Become a Flashpoint in Moscow
There is a peculiar earlier chapter to this story. In 'Robinson Tours: When Did the Money Really Run Out?', we traced the background as far as Moscow. In the Russian history linked to Robinson, serious disputes also arose in 2020 over insurance and financial guarantees. (Szallodablog.)
We do not conflate the two cases. They involve different countries, legal entities, insurers and legal frameworks. The parallel is commercial rather than legal: the real substance of an insurance policy becomes critically important when a tour operator can no longer perform its obligations and the passenger needs precisely the protection that was meant to be available in that situation.
Negligence or Deception?
We cannot yet answer that question responsibly, and that is exactly why the sentence ends with a question mark.
We do not know the exact turnover Robinson declared to Axiom or how Hungarian sales were included. We have not seen the complete original insurance questionnaire, so we cannot know exactly how the charter question was framed. We do not know for certain who was Electra Airways' direct contractual charter partner or what role the agent and broker mentioned by Electra played. Nor do we yet know what substantive checks Bulgaria's Ministry of Tourism carried out before registering the policies.
The entire chain must be examined: what did Robinson declare; what did Axiom ask and verify; who was actually responsible for the charter; how was charter activity interpreted; and what did the authority check?
Szalloda.blog has contacted Bulgaria's Ministry of Tourism with these questions. The ministry indicated that it would send a detailed professional reply shortly. Once received, we will compare it with Axiom's responses, the insurance documents and the information subsequently uncovered about Robinson's actual business activities.
The legal, regulatory, industry and international information used in this article reflects the position as of 1 September 2026. Artificial intelligence, including ChatGPT and Claude, assisted with collecting, comparing and organising the material. Final editing, interpretation and conclusions reflect szalloda.blog's editorial position. AI tools also assisted with certain illustrations and infographic elements.
This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.
.png)




Comments