top of page

Who Rates the Hotel Raters?

Writer: Pakuts Tamás
Pakuts Tamás
2 days ago
14 min read

What Is a Hotel Star Worth, and What Does It Mean Today?


Is Hotelstars Still Modern? Is Hungary's Mandatory Hotel Classification Credible and Reliable?


When evaluating any classification system, I would first ask whether it establishes that a hotel meets the requirements of a particular category or whether it tells us how good the hotel really is. These are very different things. A hotel can have the required room size, amenities, sockets, hangers, minibar, room service and reception hours and accumulate enough points while guests encounter a mediocre, impersonal, poorly operated property. Equally, a lower-category hotel may be so well managed, attentive and guest-centred that we would much rather return there than to a five-star property that meets every formal requirement but lacks genuine hospitality.


We have examined this issue before in 'Inside Hotel Operations: What Guests Do Not See May Determine Their Experience'. Front office, housekeeping, maintenance, food and beverage, revenue management, HR, technology, quality assurance and leadership form one connected system. The guest experiences only the result. Operations are the product: guests do not care which department made an error, only that something did not work. The same applies to classification: guests do not buy a checklist, but what the hotel's operation delivers.


Hotel professionals know that genuine quality is often revealed in moments difficult to reduce to tick-box criteria. How is an exhausted late arrival welcomed? What does reception do when a room has a fault? Does a waiter notice someone waiting? Can an employee solve a complaint rather than quote procedure? How is housekeeping on the third day of a full-occupancy week? Does the property perform well when no auditor, owner or VIP is watching? Quality emerges from these small interconnected encounters; modern ratings should assess far more than the presence of objects and services.


The Stars Remained While the Industry Around Them Changed


My professional position is clear: I regard Hotelstars' basic philosophy as too rigid and partly outdated. I recognise the work involved and the value of comparability and transparent requirements for three, four or five stars. My criticism is not of standards themselves, but of a system that still too readily derives a hotel's quality from objects, facilities, technical requirements and countable points.


Hotelstars no longer measures only room size and furnishings. Its current system has 239 mandatory and optional criteria, revised every five years, and it says it adapts to digitalisation, sustainability, changing guest needs and new hotel concepts. These are worthwhile improvements, but the basic limitation remains: Hotelstars is a stronger categorisation system than a comprehensive evaluation of operational quality and lived guest experience.


Hospitality is much more than the sum of a property's objects and amenities. It is the combination of architecture, design, atmosphere, people, management, processes, human reactions and individual needs. Excellent beds, luxury bathrooms and elegant lobbies may coexist with a lack of natural attention. Less spectacular or lower-category hotels may leave guests remembering not surfaces or technical specifications but the way they were treated.


Our earlier article 'Unique Places, Regional Flavours, Shared Spirit', using Singular Places as an example, found that distinctiveness, personal hosting, local roots, gastronomy, stories and atmosphere can produce quality that star ratings, room counts and lists cannot adequately convey. Much of hospitality's value arises where the classic criteria tables are least able to measure it.


Guests Have Long Since Stopped Looking Only at Stars


Thirty years ago, three, four or five stars in a travel-agency catalogue were often the most useful advance information about a hotel. There was no Booking.com, Google Reviews or Tripadvisor, no instant access to hundreds of guest photographs, negative reviews, management responses and comparisons with five competitors that same evening.


Today guests often know more about a hotel's daily weaknesses before arriving than a sign on its façade could ever tell them. They examine review averages, guest photos, breakfast, recurring problems, management replies and value-for-money assessments. Stars have not become meaningless, but no longer hold their near-exclusive former role. Formal classification ought therefore to focus much more on what today's guests seek: predictably good experience.



Twenty-Two Countries Are Not Europe, and Hotelstars Is Not an EU Standard


One common misconception needs correcting. Hotelstars Union is not the EU's official hotel-classification system, is not created by EU legislation and is not a compulsory EU standard. Founded by seven countries under HOTREC in 2009, it reached twenty-two members with Slovakia's accession in April 2026.


Its twenty-two members are Austria, Azerbaijan, Belgium, Czechia, Denmark, Estonia, Georgia, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Latvia, Liechtenstein, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Malta, the Netherlands, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland and Armenia. Seventeen belong to the European Union, while Azerbaijan, Georgia, Liechtenstein, Switzerland and Armenia do not. Ten of the EU's twenty-seven member states are outside Hotelstars.


The ten missing EU members include France, Spain, Italy, Portugal, Ireland, Finland, Croatia, Cyprus, Romania and Bulgaria. It is therefore more precise to call Hotelstars a harmonised international or European professional scheme than an 'EU standard'.



Eurostat's 2025 figures provide a better measure of European market weight than country counts. Spain recorded 513.6 million guest nights, Italy 476.9 million, France 471.7 million and Germany 442.1 million. Together they accounted for 61.7% of EU nights, yet only Germany is a Hotelstars member. Spain, Italy and France represented over 1.46 billion nights, close to half of all EU tourism, without belonging to the scheme.


That says considerably more about its real reach than the twenty-two-member headline. Hotelstars matters, but much of Europe's largest tourism markets operate without it. The organisation itself notes the national systems in France and Portugal, seventeen regional schemes in Spain, twenty-one in Italy and no official star classification in Finland and Norway. Different political, institutional and market structures explain these approaches.



Europe Has Not Abandoned Stars; It Has Developed Different Answers


It is wrong to assume countries outside Hotelstars lack classification or quality assurance. Many have their own systems, sometimes accompanied by labels for quality, service, identity or experience. Their examples show that a modern hotel need not communicate everything through a single number.


In France, Quality Does Not End with the Fifth Star


France operates its own one-to-five-star national system. Importantly, inspections are not simply conducted by Atout France or its own internal auditors, but by external inspection organisations accredited by COFRAC. According to Atout France, accreditation establishes competence and impartiality, while the accredited bodies undergo regular external surveillance audits.


France goes further at the upper end. One-to-three-star assessments are announced, while four- and five-star classifications include an anonymous mystery visit. That is a fundamental methodological difference: facilities and available services alone are insufficient when trying to judge higher-category hospitality. Inspectors must also experience a hotel when its people do not know they are being assessed.


Above five stars, France has its regulated Distinction Palace. It identifies exceptional five-star hotels for location, architecture, historical or aesthetic significance, services and outstanding experience. Thirty-three French hotels held this designation in 2026.


This is not a French invention of a sixth star. It recognises that the five-star category itself does not capture the enormous differences between properties within it.


In Spain, Stars and the Quality 'Q' Mean Different Things


Hotel classification in Spain is the responsibility of autonomous communities, resulting in seventeen regional systems. Alongside these exists a separate national quality-assurance layer, Q Calidad Turística.


Q is not another star, but an audited professional quality certificate. Spain therefore separates a hotel's accommodation category from the quality-assurance standard its operations achieve. Those are increasingly important distinct questions in hospitality.


Italy Also Attempts to Measure 'Italian Hospitality' as a Value in Its Own Right


Hotelstars reports twenty-one legally compulsory regional hotel-classification regimes in Italy. Italy also has Ospitalità Italiana, which evaluates service quality, guest orientation, property condition and local character, rather than simply repeating star ratings.


A hotel in Florence, Sicily or South Tyrol is more than the sum of amenities. Local identity, cuisine, architecture, hosting style and ties to the surroundings can determine its guest experience. A rigid universal checklist can capture these only partially.


Portugal Shows That the Story of a Property Can Be a Category


Portugal has its own national hotel classification, while the Pousadas illustrate how stars can be complemented by descriptions of character. Official tourism information divides them into Historic, Historic Design, Nature and Charm.


A property in a former monastery, castle or exceptional landscape cannot be fully described as four or five stars. Guests buy a place, story and character too, which do not fit neatly into the same one-to-five scale.


Ireland Attempts to Evaluate the Entire Guest Journey


Fáilte Ireland's Welcome Standard explicitly examines critical points along the guest journey: pre-arrival contact, arrival, welcome, assistance during the stay, complaint handling, consistent daily operations and departure.


This is modern thinking. The hotel experience neither begins at the room door nor ends at checkout. Reservation, communication, initial human contact, problem solving, departure and follow-up all belong together, and quality assurance should examine them as one journey.


Switzerland Is a Hotelstars Member Yet Knows Stars Do Not Tell the Whole Story


Switzerland is especially interesting because it helped found Hotelstars but has built additional positioning and quality layers. Switzerland Tourism's 'Typically Swiss Hotels and Lodgings' label does not ask whether a property is three, four or five stars; it asks whether it conveys an authentic Swiss experience.


Requirements include an attractive location, authentic regional architecture, interiors with Swiss character, Swiss cuisine, personal service and quality. More than 130 properties appear in the official database, from guesthouses and rural inns to palace hotels.


This demonstrates the value of different information layers. A four-star hotel can also be Typically Swiss, a wellness property, family hotel, design hotel or heritage site. Guests can understand its comfort category, audience, distinctiveness and experience separately instead of extracting everything from a single number.


That relates to our earlier article on Singular Places: travellers buy authentic, coherent experiences rather than administrative categories. A property conveying genuine local character may mean more to some visitors than a higher-star hotel that could stand anywhere in the world.


In Hungary an Optional International Scheme Became a Mandatory State System


Hungary presents a more serious additional question: accommodation classification is compulsory, not a voluntary professional service or marketing tool. Government Decree 40/2025 (III. 11.) requires providers to request assessment by the designated classification body, the Hungarian Tourism Quality Certification Body, which describes the task as one assigned to it by the state.


When government compels businesses to enter a particular classification system, it creates a correspondingly high obligation for the system itself. Professional standards, independence, transparency, conflict-of-interest safeguards and credible appeal routes should all withstand rigorous scrutiny.


In Hungary, the site inspection is performed by a two-expert Classification Committee; a five-member Review Committee then decides on category. For hotels, two reviewers are appointed by the classification body, one is proposed by MSZÉSZ subject to the body's approval, and another two are appointed by MTÜ.


This can be called broad professional representation: the classification body, industry association and state tourism administration all participate. But professional participation is not the same as institutional independence.


Our earlier article on the hotel association also examined the relationship between advocacy and independence. The question is not whether individual professionals work conscientiously, but what institutional ties, dependencies and conflicting roles surround them. Credibility rests on transparency of the overall arrangement, not just individual integrity.


In 'Trust or an Inner Circle?' we discussed the tension between personal relationships and merit. Even a professionally sound decision can lose credibility if selection and review are insufficiently transparent. The same principle applies to rating: it is not enough to declare auditors independent. The system must be constructed so their independence is visible and verifiable from outside.


Hungarian law does contain personal conflict-of-interest protections, which are necessary and right. The question of institutional independence nevertheless remains. Under the Trade Act, complaints concerning classification procedures are decided by the head of the classification organisation in administrative proceedings.


I would prefer stronger external safeguards in a compulsory scheme: truly independent accredited auditors or inspection bodies, regulated auditor rotation, public competence requirements and an appeal mechanism institutionally separate from the structure that made the original classification. France's COFRAC-based model shows this can be done in Europe.


Eight Days Are Enough for a Hotel to Put on Its Exam-Day Face


Another major methodological problem is the announced on-site inspection. Applicable Hungarian regulations require notifying a property of the inspection date at least eight days in advance.


There are practical reasons: inspectors must see rooms, operational areas and documentation, and suitable contacts need to be present. A lengthy compliance inspection must be organised. That makes sense as compliance work. The difficulty starts when we extrapolate from such an arranged visit to how good the hotel's ordinary service actually is.


Anyone who has managed a hotel, received a brand audit or prepared for an important owner visit knows the response to advance notice. Rooms are rechecked, maintenance lists reviewed, public areas and documents inspected, housekeeping briefings expanded, front-desk standards rehearsed, breakfast staff especially attentive, and more managers walk the floors than on an ordinary Tuesday. Nothing about preparing for known inspection is inherently dishonest.


The result primarily demonstrates that a hotel can meet category criteria on a particular day. It reveals less about what happens two weeks later on a fully booked Sunday evening when three guests are waiting at reception, air-conditioning fails in one room, housekeeping is exhausted, fewer managers are present and the team has no idea an ordinary-looking guest might be an inspector.


That is the real test of quality: not what a property delivers on a scheduled assessment day, but how consistently it delivers the same standard when nobody is watching specially.



Forbes Starts Looking Where I Think Real Hotel Quality Begins


Of current international assessment models, the philosophy closest to mine is Forbes Travel Guide. Forbes was not built for the same purpose as a complete national one-to-five-star classification and mainly covers the upper and luxury segments. It would be simplistic to replace every Hotelstars chart tomorrow with Forbes. But its methodology is closer to what modern hotel-quality measurement should be.


Forbes inspectors arrive anonymously, assess each rated property in person, stay at least two nights and consider as many as 900 objective standards. Forbes pays the assessment costs itself, and ratings cannot be purchased. More importantly, although facilities and service are both assessed, it places greater emphasis on service because guests remember not only the surroundings but how they felt.


An anonymous inspector follows the same check-in procedure as any guest, uses the same facilities, calls, asks questions, waits, seeks help, dines and may report an issue. The hotel cannot know whom to treat especially well. The one sound strategy is therefore to treat every guest consistently well.


The difference is not simply 900 criteria versus Hotelstars' 239. More criteria do not automatically create a better system. Forbes follows the guest journey from reservation to departure, giving attention simultaneously to cleanliness, efficiency, staff knowledge, natural service, comfort, personal attention and the complete experience.


We made a related argument in 'Hotel to Villa: Is the Suite No Longer Enough?' Modern luxury increasingly means control, privacy, personalisation and service that works almost invisibly rather than only spectacular spaces or square metres. Rating systems must be sensitive to how such luxury is actually experienced.


Modern Luxury Cannot Be Measured in Hangers and Square Metres


The limits of traditional stars show most sharply at the luxury end because luxury itself has changed. It is no longer only about collecting objects, amenities and visual spectacle. Luxury can mean space, quiet, time, privacy, naturalness and the ability to personalise a stay without making a theatrical performance of it.


It can mean guests not having to repeat requests, the hotel remembering preferences, staff appearing when needed and withdrawing discreetly when not, or a complaint handled so elegantly that the guest later remembers the recovery rather than the fault. These characteristics are hard to measure with classical category criteria, yet frequently distinguish a good luxury hotel from an exceptional one.


That is why Forbes' service- and experience-oriented philosophy appeals to me when we discuss genuine quality rather than mere categorisation. Hotelstars can say which objective category conditions are fulfilled. I want to know how the property operates on ordinary days, reacts to unexpected events, what culture lies behind its people and how guests feel when leaving.


Perhaps the Future Is Not Another Star System but More Understandable Information


Consider France's Palace designation, Spain's Q, Italy's Ospitalità Italiana, Portugal's Pousada categories, Ireland's journey-centred Welcome Standard and Switzerland's Typically Swiss label. All suggest that a modern hotel is too complex to express every meaningful characteristic through one number between one and five.


Category, physical comfort, service quality, experience, local identity, heritage, accessibility, sustainability and suitability for families, wellness or business travellers are different things. It is more intelligent to communicate these through separate, complementary layers than to cram every requirement into a star checklist.


I would not abolish conventional categorisation, but put it in its rightful place. Hotelstars or another objective scheme can establish minimum conditions for three, four and five stars. Above that, a truly independent anonymous Forbes-like audit could assess service and guest experience, especially in high categories. Additional credible specialist, regional and national identity labels and suitably interpreted guest reviews could form other layers.


Classification would tell us the property's category, independent anonymous auditing how well it operates, a Typically Swiss or Ospitalità Italiana label its identity, and guest reviews how paying guests actually lived the experience. Together these four types of information say far more than any one alone.


A Star Is Worth Something Only If Guests Believe Its Promise


After decades of hotel and tourism work, a hotel's real quality is not how many points it collected on a prepared list. It is how it functions on an ordinary day, the culture its leaders have built, how it responds to surprises, what it does for guests when no one watches and whether it can consistently create memorable experiences. That is why I consider today's Hotelstars too rigid and partly outdated and see Forbes Travel Guide's anonymous, service-centred model as closer to measuring actual hotel quality.


Hungary faces the additional responsibility of compulsory ratings. Where every accommodation provider is steered into one mandatory scheme, the classification structure itself should be subject to scrutiny as demanding as that applied to hotels. Independence must not only be proclaimed but institutionally demonstrated, and inspection should examine more than compliance at a scheduled visit.


The interesting question is no longer merely whether a hotel has three, four or five stars. It is who awarded them, by what method, with what independence, how much normal hotel operation they actually observed and whether what they examined justifies the quality guests infer from those stars.


For Hungary's compulsory system this is especially legitimate: who rates the raters, and how do we know the classification system itself meets the standards of quality, credibility, modernity and independence it demands of hotels?



Tamás Pakuts has worked in aviation and tourism for almost 35 years and in hospitality and hotels for over 25. As a general manager, executive, consultant and trainer, he has gained international operational and leadership experience across hotels, hotel groups, airlines and cruise companies, from daily operations and quality assurance to development, crisis management, organisational change and guest experience.


He has long argued that hospitality quality cannot be derived from infrastructure, categories and rules alone. Genuine performance appears in everyday encounters between staff and guests. Szalloda.blog therefore brings together international practice, direct operational experience and critical analysis to ask not only how tourism and hotels work, but how they could work better.


He can be contacted through Szalloda.blog for professional cooperation, consulting, hotel development, quality assurance, training and leadership development.



Sources and Professional References


Hotelstars Union and European Coverage

  • Hotelstars Union — Member Associations: the 22 members, national associations and organisational structure.

  • Hotelstars Union — Frequently Asked Questions: 239 criteria and national alternatives in France, Portugal, Spain, Italy, Finland and Norway.

  • Hotelstars Union — Slovakia Joins as the 22nd Member, April 2026.

  • Hotelstars Union — European Hotel Classification Scheme: methods, criteria and harmonisation.

Hungary — Legislation and Classification

  • Government Decree 40/2025 (III. 11.) on Accommodation Classification, National Legislation Database.

  • Hungarian Tourism Quality Certification Body — mandatory registration and the classification and review committees.

  • Act CLXIV of 2005 on Trade — complaints and appeals, National Legislation Database.

Europe's Tourism Scale

  • Eurostat — Another Record Year for EU Tourism in 2025: almost 3.1 billion nights and the 61.7% combined market share of Spain, Italy, France and Germany.

France

  • Atout France — Hôtel de tourisme: French one-to-five-star system and four-to-five-star mystery visits.

  • Atout France — Les organismes de contrôle: COFRAC-accredited external inspectors, competence and impartiality.

  • Atout France — Distinction Palace 2026: thirty-three designated hotels and selection criteria.

Forbes Travel Guide

  • Forbes Travel Guide — How We Inspect: anonymous inspectors, two-night minimum stays and independent assessment funding.

  • Forbes Travel Guide — Star Rating Methodology: up to 900 criteria, service, amenities and the full guest journey.

National and Complementary Quality Systems

  • Spain — Q Calidad Turística: audited tourism quality certification.

  • Italy — Ospitalità Italiana: hospitality and service quality scheme.

  • Portugal — Pousadas: Historic, Historic Design, Nature and Charm.

  • Ireland — Welcome Standard: the complete guest journey and service quality.

  • Switzerland — Typically Swiss Hotels and Lodgings: authentic architecture, local character, Swiss cuisine, personal service and quality.

Related Szalloda.blog Articles


AI tools including ChatGPT and Claude assisted research and the article's visual concepts.


This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.

Comments


bottom of page