top of page

When Will the Low-Cost Airline Bubble Burst?

Writer: Pakuts Tamás
Pakuts Tamás
2 days ago
4 min read


How and when did the story of low-cost airlines begin? In Europe, the model only became widely noticeable in the 1990s, with the early pioneers appearing in the English-speaking market. In the United States, however, similar operating models had already existed for years.


Until recently, most travellers paid little attention to what to expect from a traditional airline as opposed to a low-cost carrier. They became conscious of the differences only when something went wrong — a delay, a cancellation, lost luggage or another disruption — and the cold, harsh reality became impossible to ignore.


And that is before we consider the financial models. Traditional carriers generally employ conservative accounting and maintain clearly separated funds. Some low-cost airlines, however, have been established with very little capital, relying on promises of flights that do not yet exist and aircraft not yet purchased or leased. In effect, they make passengers investors and risk-bearers without their knowledge, while giving those passengers no say whatsoever in the airline's finances or strategy.


The low-cost model was built on continuously expanding markets and the resulting surge in passenger numbers. In some respects, it resembles a snowball effect or multilevel marketing system, with corresponding limitations and pitfalls. Market growth is finite, and the model may not sufficiently account for political, economic or pandemic risks. Low-cost carriers also tend to speculate more actively in fuel, aircraft purchasing and financial instruments. Such positions can generate income but carry substantial risks.


It is worth considering that low-cost airlines sometimes sell tickets below the actual cost of operating a flight. How can a journey lasting several hours cost just one euro when aircraft worth tens or hundreds of millions are expensive to run, crews are well paid, fuel is costly, and airlines incur handling charges, airport and air-navigation fees, maintenance costs and more? This remains true even when low-cost carriers — and increasingly traditional airlines — find numerous ways to charge passengers extra.



Traditional airlines generally make it relatively clear which components of a fare passengers are paying for, including fuel surcharges, certain seasonal or environmental levies and airport charges. With low-cost carriers, this is often less transparent. The author argues that such practices can make it harder for passengers to recover charges that an airline ultimately does not pay after a cancellation. He also criticises overbooking and the resale of the same seat, which he regards as potentially unfair sources of additional income.


In this view, restrictive behaviour aimed at the passenger — effectively the airline's investor — appears at every level: paid customer service, poor standards, frequent delays just below compensation thresholds, misleading information, deliberate breaches of regulations, unreasonable waiting times and rejected compensation claims. Unfortunately, traditional carriers that previously handled these matters more fairly increasingly imitate a zero-service model to remain competitive.


Regulators appear powerless — or, more precisely, sometimes present themselves as powerless. Handling every case properly might overwhelm their limited administrative resources and could push some airlines out of business. Carriers, meanwhile, are well aware of these institutional weaknesses and may exploit them.


During the COVID period, one might have expected healthy competition to win back the passenger through better service and more humane communication. Instead, many travellers suddenly changed their habits and expectations, adapting to the crisis. In the meantime, airlines seemed to make the passenger even less of a priority. Months of cancellations, unreliable communication, refund and compensation problems, deliberate delays and unprepared customer-service teams left travellers deeply disappointed.



This change in passengers' priorities is visible in their greater willingness to choose traditional carriers, even at a higher fare. Travellers may expect these airlines to take more responsibility for the consequences, organisation and cost of a cancellation. Unlike many low-cost operators, traditional airlines still try to look after customers, sometimes cooperating with one another.


Travellers now prefer certainty and tend to book at the last minute. Traditional airlines are more accustomed to this pattern than low-cost carriers, whose financial model often relies heavily on advance sales. It creates serious disruption when money collected against future services is needed to fund daily operations. In effect, the piggy bank has been opened. How long can the cash generated from promises six or nine months into the future last?


I believe passenger protection requires legislation that separates ticket revenue in a protected account until the booked service has been fully delivered, without cancellation, significant delay, diversion or other non-performance. Only then should the airline be permitted to use the corresponding funds.


Such regulation would undoubtedly force major changes among carriers struggling to survive, sometimes through aggressive competition. In the long run, however, it could create a healthier, fairer airline industry that treats passengers as customers, investors, employers and purchasers whose interests must be respected.


About the author:


Aviation has shaped my life for nearly 35 years. I have worked with several airlines as an executive and consultant and have contributed to changes in bilateral agreements governing the designation of air carriers. In the mid-1990s, I co-founded an early Central and Eastern European virtual airline specialising in extraordinary transport needs. I studied international aviation law in Leipzig and earned my Airline Management qualification in Geneva.


This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.

Comments


bottom of page