Air Visegrád: a V4 airline on the wings of the Scandinavian Airlines model?
On 28 September, the Czech press reported on the possibility of creating a new airline modelled on Air France–KLM or SAS Scandinavian Airlines, established jointly by Norway, Denmark and Sweden, that would bring together major regional aviation forces as a common carrier. The idea would revive a dream more than twenty years old but might answer today's difficult conditions and potentially protect the Visegrád Four countries from aggressive expansion by major network carriers and low-cost airlines.

Who might participate in such a partnership? The report mentions a combination of LOT and CSA/Smartwings, effectively Polish and Czech contributions, while the Hungarian and Slovak governments would provide capital and take smaller ownership stakes.
In whose interest would such an airline be?

LOT, the Polish airline, is among the region's successful operators despite its ownership by the Polish state. With capable professionals and a healthier approach, LOT overcame its earlier lack of quality and reliability. Its excellent expansion strategy created a route network that makes it competitive even within its own alliance, Star Alliance, and against the much larger Lufthansa.

Austrian Airlines is hardly worth mentioning in this context: cooperation with Lufthansa has imposed serious limits on Austria's earlier successful expansion, allowing LOT, quite literally, to move into those destinations.
Such cooperation should therefore be of little interest to LOT. Its fleet size and passenger capacity, together with cooperation with Nordica and XFly, could provide a strong answer to Wizz Air, which deliberately challenges LOT in Poland and elsewhere.

In addition to its northern base through Nordica, LOT was building its own hub in Budapest, stationing aircraft and crews at Ferihegy to serve regional, short-haul and long-haul markets. In Budapest it reopened destinations that Wizz Air had previously attempted and abandoned, such as Bucharest, and met more demanding expectations through services to London City and new Adriatic and other seasonal routes.

Such a joint airline would be of greatest interest to CSA/Smartwings, the Czech government and Czech airports, especially Prague, because it might produce a more balanced or proportional distribution of traffic. As the V4 airline proposal appeared, another Czech publication was also examining Prague Airport's difficulties — raising the question of whether the timing was coincidence or deliberate.
Although CSA/Smartwings is back in the hands of its original investors and has subsidiaries in Slovakia and Hungary, it has not been able to expand significantly in the region. CSA abandoned its long-haul services, Smartwings did not become a successful low-cost carrier, and its opportunities in the charter market are limited.
Such cooperation could offer them a lifeline. They might win a larger share of the market, improve their financial position and provide V4 Air's charter operations. The arrangement could also offer protection against Wizz Air, which had tried, with limited success, to establish itself at Czech airports but would now do everything possible to open additional bases, including in Czechia.

Czech aviation could face a vacuum similar to Slovakia's if the Budapest–Bratislava–Brno–Warsaw high-speed railway is built in the coming years. Rail could then replace regional flights in both price and journey time, and travellers prioritising sustainability would choose the train.
At the time, Wizz Air operated only a few flights from Prague and was preparing to open at Pardubice. Brno, Ostrava and Karlovy Vary were not among its destinations or bases.

Slovakia's aviation market is already in a near-vacuum because of the services offered by neighbouring countries' airlines and airports. It would be the least influential potential participant. Its airports are commercially less attractive precisely because major airports are close by. Košice may be the one exception, with scope for a more important regional role than it currently has.
Slovakia has never managed to sustain a conventional scheduled airline on its own. The market has been marked by failures including Tatra Air, Sky Europe, Sam Air, Air Slovakia and Danube Wings. Most recently, that summer, Go2Sky, which focused on wet-leasing and charters, ceased operating and went bankrupt. Enter Air was struggling to survive, and the company, previously active as a wet-lease subcontractor, had also tried scheduled operations and ticket sales in a small and uncertain market.

After the collapse of Malév, Hungary's national carrier, Wizz Air and Lufthansa became the clear leaders in Hungary's market as they sought to fill the gap. Turkish Airlines, Aeroflot, Qatar Airways and Emirates also secured smaller portions, while Ryanair reinforced its Budapest presence. LOT entered somewhat later, but still in time, offsetting the delay through its hub concept and product offering.
In my view, the V4 airline concept in the form then reported could not meet the needs of its member states, nor could it compete with the Lufthansa Group. It could challenge Wizz Air only if aviation authorities took their work more seriously and supervised Wizz Air more closely. Yet the V4 countries had diminishing scope to do so after Wizz Air cleverly became a European airline by moving its oversight from the Hungarian aviation authority to EASA, the European aviation regulator, among the first to make such a move.
A major Central and Eastern European airline would make sense only if Slovenia, Croatia and the Balkan states joined the V4 countries. Even then, the only conceivable foundations for it in the region would be LOT or Wizz Air.

If Wizz Air continues to enjoy the direct and indirect support of Hungary's and other governments to the degree observed, it could place even LOT under pressure. LOT's advantages are its ability to offer good-quality long-haul service and to serve connecting passengers through a hub-based network.
The question is when Wizz Air, as a low-cost operator, will enter the transfer market and begin offering connections or feed to major airlines, as competitors such as Ryanair and easyJet might. It would not be inconceivable for the market to evolve so that LOT operated regional flights with fewer than 100 seats and long-haul services, while Wizz Air focused on short-haul routes with 180–230 seats. They could become strategic partners shaping the entire Central and Eastern European aviation market and perhaps saving both large players through the pandemic and the recovery years that follow.

About the Author:
Aviation has shaped my life for almost thirty-five years. As an executive and consultant, I have worked closely with several airlines and participated in amendments to interstate agreements concerning the designation of air carriers. In the mid-1990s I co-founded the first Central and Eastern European virtual airline specialising in special requirements. I studied international aviation law in Leipzig and earned my Airline Management diploma in Geneva.
This article was translated from the original Hungarian using artificial intelligence. The original language is Hungarian.
.png)




Comments